I want to sell you a brand new, top-of-the-line Mercedes. It will cost you fifty dollars. Really.
Ridiculous? Sure. Except it is the conversation more creative business owners have with their (potential) clients than any of us would care to admit. These are the instances when what you communicate does not match the value of what you provide. It can be too much or too little. Too much – your list of services and the description of your planning, photography, design, production, etc. overwhelms the cost. Too little – the deliverable does not justify the price no matter how well it is described. When I was an attorney, my firm charged two dollars a page for a fax – sent and received. Making an outsized profit is a sure way to alienate clients.
Yes, disconnects create distrust between you and your client, employees, vendors, even colleagues. And distrust is the seed of discontent. However, what is more insidious about disconnects than the distrust they cause is the statement of ego they represent. No one consciously creates a disconnect. They exist because part of the business remains unexamined. You, the creative business owner, actually believe the fiction you are telling yourself and refuse to acknowledge the mixed message you are sending out to the world.
Harsh words? Of course. The reason I use them: your fiction can affect all creative businesses. If a photographer can give away digital files even though it takes hours to create them because she believes that that is what clients demand, then those who know better suffer for it. Will there be opportunity for those artists willing to educate and act with integrity? Yes – but moving against the proverbial tide is never easy and gets harder with each disconnect perpetuated in a given industry. There may be no one right answer, but there surely is a wrong one. Every time a creative business establishes a precedent that makes no sense in its industry you hand power over to those (clients, vendors, colleagues) who will refuse to acknowledge the strength of the art behind the business. It will become all about the money and the disconnect will only validate that you are just trying to rip them off anyway. So not a place any of us wants to be.
Does every artist and creative business owner have disconnects? Yes. We all live based on our own predispositions, values, teachings, morality and internal compass. Over time, we can all come to see that our worldview was off, sometimes way off. We can only learn and go forward with integrity and humility that, despite our best intentions, we were wrong.
What I am talking about here is when you are shown the other side and you choose to do nothing about it. Today, you have to work hard to ignore the feedback and information coming your way about you, your art and your creative business. Whether it is because it is how you have always done it, are scared to change, refuse to believe anything is wrong or are too deep in the mud to hear anyone or thing, it does not matter. Your suffering will continue (and grow) the longer the disconnect stays around. When you choose to know better, you will be better. However, if you do know better and choose not to own your responsibility to rid the disconnects in your industry please do not complain when you, your art and your creative business becomes marginalized. Value is created when the story we all tell reflects the ethos of the art behind it. Disconnects undermine the ethos of a creative business’ art in their contradiction. The biggest disconnect of all will be your belief that the disconnect others suffer from but you do not will not affect you. You are wrong. Best to do your part to stop the disconnects you see in yourself and other creative businesses in their tracks.
{ 4 comments }
Interesting take – But you fail to address a whole segment of the market. Of course there are the Mercedes driving, Steakhouse eating, single malt drinking population that values the post processing work we do to our photographs. Not only do they value it, they can afford it.
However, there is also the NASCAR watching, McDonald’s eating beer drinking folks who don’t really want (or care) about hours of post processing, and just want the digital files. Nothing fancy. Just a fast edit (and if you can get it right in camera the editing time is even less).
I’d love to hear your opinions on this group, too.
Thanks very much for the comment Eric. To me, the disconnect isn’t necessarily disparate markets, it is photographers trying to serve each of them the same way. You can’t be all things to all people and if you want the NASCAR watching, McDonald’s eating set, don’t value (or offer) the processing the Mercedes driving, Steakhouse eating set wants and pays for. Alienating no one alienates everyone.
So just to follow up –
You and I both know that the photographers who don’t charge for their services won’t be around in a couple of years. Unfortunately the barrier to entry to becoming a wedding photographer is so low, that there will be lots of replacements, and no matter how hard you or I try, they won’t ever learn.
Hi Eric! Remember me from the OSP days? 🙂 Great to see you following Sean Low too…LOVE this blog. One of these days I’ll pull the trigger and give him a ring. Hi Sean too!
Interesting conversation and blog post as always. And it’s so true what Sean says (as usual…finger on the pulse). I am in the process of hiring some folks for my business and one of them said to me “but, Geneve, what about the regular working folks? If someone isn’t rich, they can’t have great photography?” She was referring to my portrait pricing, which apparently she thought was astronomical. It was food for thought…and think I did.
I spoke with her again and told her that it’s all about what the client values. If the client wants an amazing portrait experience, then they will find a way to hire me. Vicki Taufer of V Gallery always inspires me in this arena too–she has clients, as do I, that pay me in installments. I also have the mercedes driving ones that don’t think twice about dropping $3K for session + pieces. Both of them are the backbones of my business.
So I think it’s more important than ever to truly search for the spark in your creative voice that will in turn spark the right clients. And don’t be shy about charging what you have to…and also about offering a payment plans/alternatives for clients who really love your unique vision.
I used to be all over the place with my work, and while I’m still honing this (work in progress as is every small business owner I believe! part of the fun for sure!), I’ve discovered that my unique voice is quirky, fun, a little off beat, pretty/romantic…and rather than trying to mold my work to fit what I think clients will want (I have officially stopped doing corporate head shot work for now…never was a good fit and maybe never will be), I want the clients who immediately respond at a gut level to my work to move mountains to work with me…and the rest, well , I gladly wish they hire someone else who will make them happy.
Sorry for the long post (my daughter is taking a bath and I have about 12 minutes to do this…haha).